Taynement
Featured

It’s A Good Show But…

Image result for the americans

I follow a bunch of critics on twitter and one day scrolling through I saw a bunch of them praising Fargo (you know how critics are the biggest members of groupthink). I’d already complained to a friend how I wasn’t digging this third installment of Fargo. As I read the praise and thought back on the episodes, on paper, I should be into it but for some reason, it just isn’t doing it for me. This made me think about how I feel this way about a couple of shows. Like technically, everything is on point. Acting is good. Storyline good but it just feels like a chore to watch for me.

I know I am very big on enjoyability-factor. I can recognize a show is full of flaws but because I enjoy it so much, I’d rank it high. So I think that is probably what it is for me. The biggest show culprit of this for me is The Americans. This is a show when people ask me “is it good?” I really don’t know how to answer. Because again, technically everything about it is actually good but when I see it on my DVR or I am about to watch I have to do psyche my TV muscles to get myself through it. I think the best answer is “Yea, it’s a good show but I am not sure I would recommend it” But then, if you wouldn’t recommend a show to someone, is it a good show?

Better Call Saul is another show I feel falls in this category. I am constantly blown away by the acting by Bob Odenkirk, Rhea Seehorn and Jonathan Banks on this show and I have hooped and hollered at a scene or two but ask me if it’s good and I will stutter. To be fair, I truly felt this way about it’s parent show, Breaking Bad till season 3 and deep down in the recesses of my mind I wonder if the show would hold up if I rewatched it. Some other shows I think are examples are Fargo (seasons 2 and 3 as season 1 is one of the best things ever), Preacher and Billions (I was going to say Westworld but I don’t even think it’s a good show so…)

Not to be hypocritical, I feel a lot of people would put Leftovers in this category but I think Leftovers probably falls in the new wave of shows where we don’t know wtf is going on and are too intelligent for their own good. I will completely agree to feeling like season 1 Leftovers falls with this group but even though I still don’t know what is going on, I actually look forward to watching it and I don’t have to take a deep breath before pressing play. Now would I recommend this show to someone? It’ll probably come with a caveat.

One last point to take into consideration, is wondering if I would feel the same way about these shows if I was a binger vs. watching week to week? I know a friend who binged The Americans and just couldn’t stop gushing about it. To me, I felt so weak thinking about if I had to binge that show. I’d like to know what you think? What shows do you consider a technically good show but when it’s time to watch you don’t feel so gingered and save it for last on your DVR?

Related posts

My 2015 Oscar Predictions

taynement
10 years ago

Best and Worst of Billboard Music Awards Red Carpet

taynement
9 years ago

Season 2 “Empire” Promo Poster

taynement
9 years ago
Exit mobile version