My Thoughts on #ShesGottaHaveIt

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp

Post By

taynement

Image result for she's gotta have it tv

She’s Gotta Have It is a Netflix TV reboot of the 1986 Spike Lee movie (which I have not seen) of the same name. It tells the story of Nola Darling. A young black woman who is trying to juggle life in Brooklyn. It follows her life with her friends, her career and the three men (and one woman) that she is dating. Well, dating is the wrong word when it comes to Nola, as she is a commitment phobe and does not believe in being exclusive in a relationship. So basically, she is in a sexual relationship with all 4 and they all know that they aren’t the only one she is sleeping with.

There’s Jamie – The older married man who can be a bit uptight.

Mars – the child like sneaker head who adores Nola completely (of the three he seemed the most good for Nola if she ever decided to have a boyfriend. He prayed for her, made her laugh and always came through for her when she needed it. True embodiment of what you need not always coming in the package you want)

Greer – narcissistic model and photographer who screams out his own name during sex

It’s a little difficult for me to convey how I feel about the show as I don’t want to undermine the good parts of it and I don’t want to play down its flaws. I think it was a watchable and even enjoyable conscious comedy. Conscious because it’s blackness was front, right and center and couldn’t be missed. I liked how it touched on totally relevant topics such as street harassment, body image issues while also paying homage to prolific black musicians of old (the show constantly toes the line and veers into pretentious land but I really liked the one episode that had Nola visiting the graves of black musicians past)

I thought about it for a long time and I think I decided what was bugging me about the show and I think it’s the casting. Granted I don’t know what tone Spike Lee was going for but I didn’t feel any of the characters were believable. They almost all seemed like caricature characters playing in a satire and I wanted to turn the volume down.

DeWanda Wise who plays Nola is GORGEOUS. A striking beauty of a woman but I just never fully bought in. Especially during scenes when she was mad. Greer is supposed to be this debonair, suave man and all I kept thinking is when is he going to come out the closet? Everything seemed forced and not fluid. Same could be said of the sex scenes. What was Fat Joe’s character supposed to be? Has his voice always been that screechy? I do have to say I really enjoyed Shemekka as a character.

I am always vocal about why writers make the lead female character on most shows hella annoying and selfish and this was no exception. I found Nola to be selfish which seems harsh considering she was there for Shemekka and Papi their mayor but overall she seemed bratty but I think that comes with still figuring things out and not having any direction?

There were two inconsistencies I noticed that nagged at me – first, when Jamie had this talk with his son and his son one minute was arguing that this generation is different and more accepting of stuff and few minutes later when his son says this is how race is now, his same son says “now? it’s been that way for a while” :/ and second when Nola rails at Jamie for letting her down and she says “I am tired of people like you letting me down all the time!” and I am thinking but Mars has been there for you every single time.

I do want to point out how this show made me pause and think for a moment. Nola is a sexually liberated woman who has no qualms sleeping with whoever and no strings attached. My first thought when I watched was thinking how she seemed like an addict who didn’t want to be alone and she wasn’t truly this free, sexual person. Then I saw tweet that said “Real talk though, she is a ho”. That made me pause and wonder why it was hard for me to believe this was what Nola really wanted but if it was a man, I would have accepted without question.

Another instance was with the episode that dealt with a provocative black dress Nola wore that elicited similar responses from each of the men that insinuated that she was asking for whatever came her way wearing a dress like that. Each time, Nola was adamant as to why she had a right to wear whatever she wanted to and that really made me check myself because before that I think I was on the fence and thinking well you should be able to wear whatever you want but you have to know what comes with it.

Overall, the sub-par acting or bad casting notwithstanding, I would recommend the show. It definitely had its over preaching, pretentious doing too much moments but it’s a good binge show and since it is 30 minutes of 10 episodes, it goes by fast. Also, the show does a cool thing of where for each song it played in a scene (and they were hella dope songs), the album cover would be shown at the end of the scene. That was really cool. I hear the playlist is on Apple so, something to check out if you are interested.

P.S It was kinda cool to see Heather Headley pop up as an actor after many years of being gone. Has she always had an accent?

Fun Fact – The woman who plays Nola’s mom is Joie Lee. Writer on the show and also Spike Lee’s sister. Also, the show’s title music is called “Nola” and is written by Bill Lee – Spike Lee’s dad.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp

Leave a Reply

5 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Lari
Lari
November 27, 2017 12:15 am

Yaayyy I was waiting for your thoughts :). I definitely agree about the casting for Greer. His voice, mannerisms, etc. were just over the top and not true to the “sexy” character that he was supposed to play. I did go back and watched the original after finishing the series. I feel the other characters were a better, more fleshed out versions of the original casting. I really enjoyed Mar’s character, and I was intrigued with how the plot was going to develop with Nola’s character. I kept debating whether I liked Nola or not throughout the season. I didn’t… Read more »

Lari
Lari
December 1, 2017 8:53 am
Reply to  taynement

The original is also on Netflix

Thesagemorgan
Thesagemorgan
June 4, 2019 3:07 am

I really loved this review as it captures my thoughts perfectly. I saw your tweet that said you preferred season 2 to season 1 and I wonder why. Also, the scene where Nola lashes out at Jaime for being like other people, I think it’s because she secretly liked Jaime more than her other partners especially Mars? Jaime was more mature & convenient and I think if he was single without drama from his nuclear family, things might have worked out between both of them. Furthermore, I agree that some parts of the acting was too much but decided that… Read more »

Recent Post

5
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x